EB-2 NIW · Common RFE topics
What USCIS questions, the legal standard it applies, and the kinds of evidence petitioners usually provide. General information, not a response strategy for your case.
Eligibility criteria
- Advanced degree and experience in the specialtyWhether you hold an advanced degree or its equivalent, and whether the intended occupation is a profession.
- Exceptional abilityWhether you meet three of six criteria and show expertise significantly above the ordinary in an area tied to your endeavor.
- Substantial merit and national importanceWhether your specific endeavor has substantial merit and national importance (Dhanasar prong one).
- Well positioned to advance the endeavorWhether you are well positioned to advance your endeavor (Dhanasar prong two).
- On balance, the waiver benefits the United StatesWhether the factors for waiving the job offer and labor certification outweigh the reasons for requiring them (Dhanasar prong three).
Specific evidence
- Defining the proposed endeavorWhether the petition clearly describes a specific endeavor, not just an occupation.
- Evidence of progress and outside interestWhether there is evidence of steps taken toward the endeavor and of interest from customers, users, investors, or others.
Recent AAO decisions
OfficialAAO decisions only include cases that were denied and then appealed. They show why some petitions fail — they are not an approval rate.
What the AAO did (this sample of 145, May 15, 2026 – Aug 31, 2026): Appeal dismissed 94% · Appeal sustained 0% · Remanded 6%“Remanded” means sent back to the service center for a new decision — not an approval.
- Aug 31, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 31, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 28, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 28, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 26, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 26, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 24, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 24, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 24, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 22, 2026Appeal dismissed
Source: USCIS AAO non-precedent decisions · Retrieved Sep 27, 2026
This information is for general informational purposes and is not legal advice. It does not create an attorney-client relationship and does not predict the outcome of any individual case.