EB-1A · Common RFE topics
What USCIS questions, the legal standard it applies, and the kinds of evidence petitioners usually provide. General information, not a response strategy for your case.
Specific evidence
- Lesser national or international awardsWhether an award you received is nationally or internationally recognized for excellence in your field.
- Membership requiring outstanding achievementWhether an association admits members based on outstanding achievements judged by recognized experts.
- Published material about youWhether articles or coverage are about you and your work and appeared in qualifying media.
- Judging the work of othersWhether you actually served as a judge of others' work in your field or an allied field.
- Original contributions of major significanceWhether your original work has had major significance in your field.
- Authorship of scholarly articlesWhether you have authored scholarly articles in qualifying publications, and what their caliber shows.
- Artistic exhibitions or showcasesWhether your own work was displayed at artistic exhibitions or showcases.
- Leading or critical roleWhether your role was leading or critical for an organization, or a division of one, with a distinguished reputation.
- High salary or remunerationWhether your pay is high compared with others in your field, using reliable comparison data.
- Commercial success in the performing artsWhether sales or box office results show commercial success compared with others in the performing arts.
- Comparable evidenceWhether a criterion truly does not readily apply to your occupation, and whether the substitute evidence is truly comparable.
Eligibility criteria
- Final merits determinationWhether the record as a whole shows sustained acclaim and a place among the small percentage at the very top of your field.
- Sustained acclaimWhether your national or international acclaim has been maintained over time.
- Continuing work in your fieldWhether you will keep working in your area of extraordinary ability in the United States.
Recent AAO decisions
OfficialAAO decisions only include cases that were denied and then appealed. They show why some petitions fail — they are not an approval rate.
What the AAO did (this sample of 150, May 28, 2026 – Aug 31, 2026): Appeal dismissed 82% · Appeal sustained 0% · Remanded 18%“Remanded” means sent back to the service center for a new decision — not an approval.
- Aug 31, 2026Remanded
- Aug 31, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 27, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 27, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 27, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 26, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 26, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 25, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 25, 2026Appeal dismissed
- Aug 25, 2026Remanded
Source: USCIS AAO non-precedent decisions · Retrieved Sep 27, 2026
This information is for general informational purposes and is not legal advice. It does not create an attorney-client relationship and does not predict the outcome of any individual case.